Amid accusations quarterback De’Andre Johnson hit a 21-year-old woman in a Tallahassee bar two weeks ago, Florida State suspended the freshman indefinitely June 25.
After a surveillance video surfaced of the incident Monday, Seminoles coach Jimbo Fischer announced Johnson had been dismissed from the program.
The video, released by the Florida State Attorney’s office, depicts Johnson and the woman entering a shoving match at a bar before the woman threw a punch. Johnson retaliated with a blow to the woman’s face and exited the frame.
The woman in the video suffered bruising near her left eye, swelling of the left cheek and upper lip, and a small cut near the bridge of her nose, according to court records.
Johnson, widely thought to be in the thick of Florida State’s quarterback derby, is accused of misdemeanor battery, according to assistant state attorney George Cappleman. He turned himself into police last Tuesday and was released on a $500 bond.
Almost a year ago, Oklahoma found itself in a similar situation.
Then-freshman running back Joe Mixon, newly arrived to campus, struck OU student Amelia Molitor in a Norman restaurant early the morning of July 25. Molitor claimed the blow broke bones in her face in four places.
Mixon was charged with a misdemeanor count of acts resulting in gross injury and entered an Alford Plea in October, accepting a one-year deferred sentence along with mandatory counseling and 100 hours of community service.
Unlike Johnson, Mixon was not dismissed from the program but rather suspended from all team activities for the 2014 season.
The difference between the two incidents? Mixon’s video was never released to the public.
Mixon’s video was shown to members of the media, however. The Daily’s Dillon Hollingsworth viewed the surveillance tape Sept. 4.
“She was probably half his size,” Hollingsworth said of the video. “She reaches up and slaps him and he rears back and he unleashed a haymaker on her. It was not pretty to see.”
Molitor immediately fell to ground, according to Hollingsworth, before Mixon quickly exited the restaurant.
“He did not hold back,” Hollingsworth said. “It wasn’t like a tap. He reared back and gave it to her.”
Among those who have viewed the Mixon video are Oklahoma coach Bob Stoops, athletic director Joe Castiglione and President David Boren.
Hollingsworth said had the video been released publically, Mixon would no longer be with the program.
“If [Oklahoma] picks up a couple of early losses and that tape comes in the midst of people being upset about the football team, that’s probably it for Bob Stoops as a head coach,” Hollingsworth said.
While it rings as merely conjecture, Hollingsworth’s statement speaks to the sickening nature of Mixon’s video.
Mixon rejoined the team for spring workouts in March.
“I’ve watched Mixon because he’s been here and I’ve been able to see him more,” Boren told the Tulsa World last week. “Discipline, academic wise, he’s done really well. He and [suspended linebacker Frank Shannon] with their colleagues have been great out there. I think they’ve gone the extra mile.”
After Florida State’s decisive action in the face of public scrutiny when the video of their own player was released, it is quite clear the only reason Mixon was given the opportunity to go ‘the extra mile’ is because the surveillance tape was kept under wraps.
According to The Daily’s Joe Mussatto, who viewed the tape along with Hollingsworth, a “faint yet audible gasp came from the back of the room as Joe Mixon’s jarring punch connected with Amelia Molitor’s face.”
Johnson’s video no doubt extracted gasps from viewers across the country, as well.
Three of the most powerful people within the OU football program viewed the Mixon tape and elected to suspend, not dismiss, the highly-touted freshman running back.
“My initial reaction the video – the FSU quarterback in the bar – was that the one of Mixon was worse,” Hollingsworth said.
A year later, it is easy to say the Oklahoma brass – Boren, Castiglione and Stoops – should have immediately dismissed Mixon after seeing the surveillance footage from the morning of July 25.
The fact remains Johnson and Mixon were involved in nearly identical incidents with one key difference – a difference that kept Mixon at Oklahoma.
While both were brutal and wrong, if Mixon’s punch was truly as bad if not worse than Johnson’s, Oklahoma – specifically its head football coach, athletic director and president – needs to pray his video is never released.
“How they ever thought, ‘Hey, we can get away without having to cut this kid,’ that’s something that baffled me after seeing the video,” Mussatto said.